SHOCKING COMMENTS “INSULT” YOUNG WORKERS, SAY INTERNS’ RIGHTS GROUPS
A recruitment company has suggested that interns should eat roadkill — including badgers and squirrels — to make ends meet during their unpaid placements.
Young workers were also advised to “return to the dark ages” as “electric lights are a luxury when perfectly good candles can be brought [sic] for pennies from Ikea.”
Other tips for surviving internship-induced poverty included sharing beds, hitchhiking and growing a beard (to save money on razors — and keep warm in winter).
Was this a joke? Shockingly, it seems not — as the list also suggested that interns shop at markets to reduce their food bills and avoid partying in central London (“Vauxhall, Brixton, Camden and Shoreditch are a lot cheaper”).
But the most bizarre part of the blog post was this oddly cheery sign-off:
“If you don’t mind being labelled an eccentric, the scope for frugality is endless; limited only by your imagination (and your dignity!)”
Sorry — does the author find the idea of interns living in humiliating poverty funny?
Because I — and the interns’ rights groups – strongly disagree.
Intern Aware has labelled the comments “offensive”, Interns Anonymous called the article “insulting” and Internocracy said internships were “no laughing matter.”
So who is responsible for the article?
The publisher of this article is none other than Inspiring Interns, the controversial recruitment company which makes its money by matchmaking interns with employers. For every month each intern works, Inspiring Interns makes £500 — while the intern earns just £200 towards their lunch and travel expenses.
(Yes, well spotted — £200 a month is far less than the National Minimum Wage).
Don’t believe that such a company exists? Believe it.
Below is the sales email that the company sends out to prospective clients, offering their services and proudly naming high profile clients including Skype and Alliance Boots (yes, the company that owns Boots the chemist. That’s two more for Graduate Fog’s list…):
Subject: www.inspiringinterns.com Low Cost Employment Solution
Hi,
We source the best candidates from around the world to find them beneficial work placements. Inspiring Interns is providing diverse companies such as AdMob, Stardoll, Skype, Alliance Boots, and Phorm with outstanding young talent. Whether you’re looking for temporary or full time staff, with majors in Computer Science or Architectural Design from Statistics to Marketing and Advertising… Whatever your requirements we can find the right match with our targeted and efficient approach.
All students are qualified and assessed by Inspiring Interns before we send them to you, so we save you time and money by conducting the first interviews. Below are example Video Profiles, if you have specific criteria fill in the attached internship job spec form, send it back to me and I’ll match it!
- Sara’s CV and Video (BA Joint Honours in French and Hispanic Studies , 2:1 — Distinction in Law)
- Peter’s CV and Video (MSc Management, BSc Business Management, 2:1)
- Shelley’s CV and Video (Bachelor of International Studies, Political Science and International Business, Bachelor of Law)
See HERE! for more examples of our candidates.
We give all interns psychometric tests to acquire their numerical, linguistic and reasoning capabilities. We aim to provide our clients with as much information as possible to ensure you are hiring the best interns relevant to your needs.
We do charge a fee for our service and you would be expected to cover the intern’s lunch and travel expenses (our fee is £500 per intern per month, and travel and lunch would be in the region of £200 per month). All inclusive it works out at about £35 per working day for an intelligent enthusiastic worker who will determinedly add value to your company.
If you would like any further information, please don’t hesitate to call.
Best regards
(To the kind soul who forwarded this to Graduate Fog and assured me you’d never use their services, thank you.)
Graduate Fog’s friends at the interns’ rights groups say they are disgusted by the ‘roadkill’ post, which appears to make light of the plight of hundreds of thousands of young workers, whose desperation for experience is forcing them to intern unpaid.
Gus Baker, co-founder of Intern Aware told me:
“Thousands of young workers are living hand to mouth to fund unpaid, unfair internships. Flippant comments like these about interns’ situations are not only offensive, but risk undermining the hard work they are doing with often no recognition or reward.”
Alex Try, co-founder of Interns Anonymous commented:
“Many of the interns who contact us are struggling to cope financially, after working for free for months. They don’t want insulting lists of money-saving tips – they want employers to pull their finger out, obey the minimum wage laws and give them proper, entry level jobs. Unless interns are claiming benefits too (or getting support from their parents), they simply can’t survive on £200. In London, a Zones 1&2 Travelcard alone is nearly £100.”
And Becky Heath, co-founder of Internocracy said:
“If internships in profit-making companies were properly remunerated according to law, interns would be able to afford to pay for housing, food and other essentials. It is hard being an intern, particularly if you’re not paid, and making significant levels of financial sacrifice isn’t a laughing matter. We are working with employers and interns to create a more diverse and accessible internship culture, and calling for a better deal for all interns in an unfair position.”
Graduate Fog’s path has crossed with Inspiring Interns’ before — and their CEO Ben Rosen seems genuinely puzzled to hear that some young workers might have a teensy problem with his company’s business model.
He is convinced that his organisation does good work as his interns happily volunteer to work for free and many have been offered jobs after their placements. I have tried to explain the bigger picture, but our differences remain. I’m afraid I have given up trying to persuade him — we no longer speak.
However, one thought continues to niggle at the back of my mind. It is widely agreed that long internships at private companies where the intern is doing the job of a ‘worker’ must be paid (even if the intern says they’re happy to work for free). So the question is, how do unpaid internships, such as the ones that Inspiring Interns promotes, fit in with current employment legislation?
I am so stumped that I contacted the Department of Business for their thoughts, pasting a copy of Inspiring Interns’ sales email into my own email and asking them to explain. My man at the Department of Business said he could not offer a statement other than to say that he had passed the information on to HMRC.
You may be surprised to hear that I have asked the officials keep the author of the ‘roadkill’ post out of their enquiries, however.
Why? Who was it?
Inspiring Interns’ very own intern, of course.
*Was Inspiring Interns’ blog post a joke — or is working unpaid no laughing matter?
Decide for yourself — here is the blog post in full (Just don’t forget to come back to Graduate Fog to tell us what you think!)
It’s been removed? Never fear, the screen shots are below:
“the best candidates …temporary or full time staff…an intelligent enthusiastic worker” should be PAID for their work! And that is before we even mention that these “candidates” have university degrees! I believe that anything else is nothing less than disgraceful! The way they are talking about the young people they are effectively selling, describing them in cold-hearted terms as if they were faceless commodities and third class citizens, undeserving of a PAID ROLE, is shocking and disgusting. This company should be shut down; their approach is, as you and your colleagues have suggested, insulting, damaging and highly offensive. This sort of attitude needs to be exterminated before it corrodes the entire job market and destroys all reasonable and fair opportunities for graduates! We cannot allow this to become the norm or to be in any way acceptable.
I disagree. We should all work for £35 a day. Then we will finally free ourselves from this capitalist stench as our financial system breaks down, the weak die out through natural selection, and I can finally get my hands on that mud hut I’ve been so keen on.
Any UK company that spends less than £35 a day on a worker deserves to have their chief exec hauled through the streets for people to throw rotten tomatoes at them.
@Christopher
You’re right. There are lots of lovely, responsible recruiters out there (like those who advertise on the Graduate Fog Job Board but there also seem to be a growing number who have a weird disconnect between themselves and their employees (if you can even call unpaid interns that). Have they somehow become de-sensitised to the fact that their business is all about people?
@John
Thanks for your comment – I’m off to stock up on tomatoes now… Fingers x’ed my man at the stall will have some mouldy ones from yesterday in the back… ; )
Having read the article I suppose the intern was trying to be “ironic” or perhaps darkly reflecting on his intern situation. But at a time like this with the issues being raised, it comes off as being in poor taste. As mentioned in the main article, partying is probably the least of interns worries, having to think about paying for transport and a place to stay. I can only imagine how horrible it would be for a struggling intern to read this. Its a joke, but a cruel one. Also I’m pretty sure that IKEA candles wouldn’t be cheap :P.
@Deepam
£1.39 for a bag of 36 tea lights!
AND they last for 3.5 hours – bargain!
However, interns should probably factor in to that cost that there’s always the risk that they could set their cardboard box – sorry, house – on fire…
; )
They don’t do psychometric tests on you. They just video you. Unless writing your name on a form is a test. Wait…
And as much as it angers me that II are profiting while I am losing money, they at least are eager to match me with something, whereas the genuine recruiter that I’ve been on the books of for six months has done nothing more than submit me for the same job twice, without realising until I pointed it out. Maybe I should work in recruitment.
******* outrageous.
Would a group legal action be useful? What if we all went out and got 3 internships at 3 different companies for a month each, say there were just 10 of us, then we could sue 30 companies at once once we finished and they refused to pay us…..
John…we’d run out of tomatoes.
I’m pretty sure that the intern was writing that post while crying inside at their horrendous situation. But I’d far rather be in an internship where they at least reimburse all my food and travel (expensive lunches, HELLO!) than do the hellish door-to-door sales job I did where you worked on commission and were expected to pay to travel to do the hellish job.